Get & compare mortgage quotes anonymously Start in My Home

Own Members 1st? Claim this free profile to add your logo, loan officers and reviews.

Claim this Profile
M1

Members 1st

Credit Union•Enola, PAHQ•Direct•Reviews near you on Google

We analyzed every closed loan from Members 1st — 690 loans across 923 applications— and benchmarked them against peer lenders across the 5 Ps of Mortgage Shopping.

Safe Rate Ratings· each scored 1–5 against peer lenders
Pricing
Sound
3/5
vs. all lenders
Pull-through
Strong
4/5
closing strength
Product
Strong
4/5
FHA · Conventional · VA
Place
Strong
4/5
Multi-Region · 9 mkts
Promptness
Not enough data
—/5
No quote responses measured yet
Safe Rate Awards
Conventional Superstar
Conventional
Superstar
FHA Superstar
FHA
Superstar
Purchase Superstar
Purchase
Superstar
Refinance Superstar
Refinance
Superstar

Safe Rate Summary

What They Do Well

  • Strong pull through performance
  • Particularly strong in Conventional and FHA loans

Explore another lender or local market

Report Card

Members 1st performance at a glance

Overall Performance· Pricing & closing strength
Pricing
Rate competitiveness
Sound
+21.5 bps above market avg
3/5
Pull Through
Closing strength
Strong
Top 40% of lenders
4/5
By Loan Product· Specialization by type
Conventional
615 loans · 0.25% above market
Strong
Top 40% of lenders
4/5
FHA
44 loans · 0.04% below market
Strong
Top 40% of lenders
4/5
VA
18 loans · 0.43% below market
Sound
Top 60% of lenders
3/5
By Loan Purpose· Transaction purpose mix
Purchase
497 loans · 0.23% above market
Strong
Top 40% of lenders
4/5
Refinance
193 loans · 0.17% above market
Strong
Top 40% of lenders
4/5
By Location· Geographic coverage
Geographic Reach
Multi-Regional · 10 markets
Strong
Top 40% of lenders
4/5

Loan Product Performance

Performance by Loan Product

Conventional
Overall
Strong
Product
Strong
Pricing
Sound
Pull Through
Strong
Volume615
Mix89.1%
Spread
+0.250%Above
Fees
$1,305Fees
FHA Loans
Overall
Strong
Product
Strong
Pricing
Exceptional
Pull Through
Strong
Volume44
Mix6.4%
Spread
-0.036%Below
Fees
$1,435Fees
VA Loans
Overall
Strong
Product
Sound
Pricing—
Pull Through
Strong
Volume18
Mix2.6%
Spread
-0.434%Below
Fees
$965Fees

Specialty Loan Performance

Performance by Specialty and Loan Type

HELOCs
Overall
Strong
Pricing
Exceptional
Pull Through
Strong
Product—
DSCR & Rental Loans
Overall
Sound
Rate comparison*
Acceptable
Pull Through
Sound
Product—
Low Down Payment
Overall
Strong
Pricing
Sound
Pull Through
Strong
Product
Strong
ARMs
Overall
Sound
Pricing—
Pull Through
Sound
Product
Sound
15-Year Loans
Overall
Sound
Pricing
Acceptable
Pull Through
Sound
Product
Strong
Second Homes
Overall
Strong
Pricing—
Pull Through
Strong
Product
Strong

* Pricing here is a rate comparison: HMDA does not report the points, prepayment penalties or origination fees on these loans, so compare full quotes from several lenders.

Loan Purpose Performance

Performance by Loan Purpose

Purchase
Overall
Strong
Product
Strong
Pricing
Sound
Pull Through
Sound
Volume497
Mix72.0%
Spread
+0.230%Above
Fees
$1,369Fees
Refinance
Overall
Strong
Product
Strong
Pricing
Sound
Pull Through
Strong
Volume193
Mix28.0%
Spread
+0.172%Above
Fees
$1,126Fees

At a Glance

Lender Overview

Lending Activity
Loans Originated
690
Applications
923
Volume
$193 million
Pricing & Closing
Avg Rate Spread
+0.215%
vs. market APOR
Avg Net Fees
$1,308
Origination − Credits
Pullthrough Rate
74.8%
Applications → Closed
Typical Borrower
Avg Loan Amount
$280,087
Avg Borrower Income
$136,642
Avg Property Value
$402,261

Geographic Coverage

Geographic Performance

Metro Areas
9
markets with activity
States Served
16
of 50 states + DC
Avg Place Specialization
Strong
4/5

States with Loan Originations

16Full-year 2024 · HMDA
16 states with loan originations
Loans originated
< 1010+None
Northeast3
NJNYPA
Midwest3
ILMOOH
South8
ARDEFLMDNCSCVAWV
West2
NVWY

Top Metro Areas by Place Specialization Score

1© Jeffrey Hayes · CC BY 2.0
Harrisburg, PAMetro
Volume 248Mix 35.94% of portfolio
100/100
Exceptional
2© Smallbones · CC0
York, PAMetro
Volume 120Mix 17.39% of portfolio
79/100
Strong
Volume 84Mix 12.17% of portfolio
78/100
Strong
4© Joe Zlomek · CC BY-SA 3.0
Gettysburg, PAMetro
Volume 32Mix 4.64% of portfolio
70/100
Strong
Volume 29Mix 4.20% of portfolio
67/100
Strong
6© Unknown · Public domain
Chambersburg, PAMetro
Volume 19Mix 2.75% of portfolio
58/100
Sound
7© Jack · CC BY-SA 2.0
Reading, PAMetro
Volume 24Mix 3.48% of portfolio
56/100
Sound
8© Dough4872 · Public domain
Montgomery County, PAMetro
Volume 25Mix 3.62% of portfolio
53/100
Sound
9© Paul Leiby · CC BY 3.0
Allentown, PA-NJMetro
Volume 19Mix 2.75% of portfolio
51/100
Sound

Top States by Place Specialization Score

Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania
1
PennsylvaniaState
Volume 646Mix 93.62% of portfolio
86/100
Exceptional
Maryland
Maryland
2
MarylandState
Volume 10Mix 1.45% of portfolio
38/100
Acceptable

How We Rank Lenders

Our rankings use an equal-weight average of scores across the 5 Ps: Pricing, Product, Pull-Through, Place, and Promptness. Promptness measures how quickly a lender answers real shopper quote requests; a lender with none measured yet is counted at an estimate.

Our Point System (Max 50 Points)

10/ 50 pts
Pricing
How competitively a lender prices vs. the market benchmark (20%).
10/ 50 pts
Product
Performance on your specific loan type (20%).
10/ 50 pts
Pull Through
How reliably a lender closes the loans it starts (20%).
10/ 50 pts
Place
Depth of a lender's expertise in your local market (20%).
10/ 50 pts
Promptness
How quickly a lender answers real quote requests — blended in once they respond (20%).
Champion
Champion(80%+ = 40-50 points)
Superstar
Superstar(60-79% = 30-39 points)

Data Integrity & Updates

Data is updated quarterly based on the latest HMDA filings and proprietary Safe Rate analysis. All metrics are calculated using standardized methodologies to ensure fair comparison across lenders.

Looking for a different lender?

The 5 PsRankings are calculated from observed lender differences on closed loans across Pricing, Pull-through, Product, and Place, plus Promptness when a lender has answered real shopper quote requests.
No Pay to PlayLenders cannot buy their way to the top. Rankings are 100% earned.
HMDA 2024Built using publicly available originated loan data from the federal government.
Peer BenchmarkedPerformance is normalized and benchmarked against peer institutions.