Get & compare mortgage quotes anonymously Start in My Home

Safe Rate Rankings

Best Conventional Mortgage Lenders in Buffalo

Updated June 4, 2026

Rankings are a starting point, not a verdict. Safe Rate recommends speaking with 2-3 lenders to find the right fit for your home loan!

The 5 PsRankings are calculated from observed lender differences on closed loans across Pricing, Pull-through, Product, and Place, plus Promptness when a lender has answered real shopper quote requests.
No Pay to PlayLenders cannot buy their way to the top. Rankings are 100% earned.
HMDA 2024Built using publicly available originated loan data from the federal government.
Peer BenchmarkedPerformance is normalized and benchmarked against peer institutions.
Total Lenders63
Total Loans10,663
Median Rate Spread0.27%
Buffalo Market Insights
  • Premium Mortgage is Safe Rate's top-ranked Conventional lender in Buffalo, leading on the 5 P's: pricing, pullthrough, Conventional product expertise, local knowledge, and promptness.
  • There is often a pricing vs. pullthrough tradeoff in mortgage lending. In Buffalo, Sefcu Services and Northwest Bank Pa scores highest on Conventional pricing while United Wholesale Mortgage and Rocket Mortgage leads on likelihood to close. That is why we encourage speaking with multiple lenders.
  • United Wholesale Mortgage (UWM) ranks #2 in Buffalo, serving as the platform behind many independent local brokers who live and work in the community. A local broker knows the neighborhoods, the local market, and is personally invested in your outcome. Real estate agents often prefer referring local brokers for their accessibility and responsiveness, qualities that matter when a deal is moving fast. Pricing and experience can vary by broker.
  • Popular names in Buffalo: Rocket Mortgage (#9) and Premium Mortgage (#1).

Explore Rankings by Type

Overall Rankings

All lenders in Buffalo

Need rankings for a different loan product?

Shopping for a mortgage? Hit Get Quote on any lender to add it to My Home and request real quotes.

1
Premium Mortgage Corporation
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,199Fees
2
United Wholesale Mortgage
Independent Mortgage CompanyWholesale
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$2,657Fees
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,442Fees
4
Homestead Funding
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,633Fees
5
SEFCU Services
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$833Fees
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,047Fees
7
Northwest Bank
BankDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,012Fees
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,208Fees
9
Rocket Mortgage
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect & Wholesale
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$3,682Fees
10
1st Priority Mortgage
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,995Fees
11
Navy Federal Credit Union
Credit UnionDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$494Fees
12
NBT Bank
BankDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$220Fees
13
CrossCountry Mortgage
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$2,690Fees
14
Citizens Bank
BankDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,334Fees
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$2,327Fees
16
Movement Mortgage
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$2,149Fees
17
CNB Bank
BankDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$848Fees
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,927Fees
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$2,322Fees
20
Hunt Mortgage Corporation
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$3,244Fees
21
Five Star Bank
BankDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,636Fees
22
Nationstar Mortgage
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$2,542Fees
23
PennyMac Loan Services
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect & Wholesale
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,463Fees
24
Plaza Home Mortgage
Independent Mortgage CompanyWholesale
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$1,938Fees
25
loanDepot
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$2,937Fees
26
CMG Mortgage
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Strong
Avg Fees
$2,684Fees
27
Community Bank
BankDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$255Fees
28
NewRez
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect & Wholesale
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$2,467Fees
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$306Credit
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$845Fees
31
Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$2,967Fees
32
American Financial Network
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect & Wholesale
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$369Fees
33
Mortgage Research Center
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$76Fees
34
Everett Financial
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$4,101Fees
35
Reliance First Capital
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$3,824Fees
36
TD Bank
BankDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$1,761Fees
37
Ownerschoice Funding
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$1,309Fees
38
Great Erie
Credit UnionDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$1,001Fees
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees—
40
UIF Corporation
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$2,427Fees
41
Freedom Mortgage Corporation
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$2,022Fees
42
Guidance Residential
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$1,935Fees
43
Royal United Mortgage
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$2,838Fees
44
Carrington Mortgage Services
Independent Mortgage CompanyDirect
Overall
Sound
Avg Fees
$3,704Fees

Frequently Asked Questions

How are mortgage lenders ranked in Buffalo?+

Safe Rate ranks lenders using the 5 Ps framework. Four are derived from HMDA (Home Mortgage Disclosure Act) data: Pricing (how competitively a lender prices loans vs. the market benchmark), Pullthrough (how effectively a lender closes applications), Place (the lender's depth of expertise in Buffalo), and Product (performance on specific loan types). The fifth, Promptness, is behavioral: it credits lenders who answer real shopper quote requests quickly. Lenders with no measured requests yet are counted at an estimated 50. Each lender receives a composite Safe Rate Score from 0 to 100. No lender pays to appear in the rankings.

What is the Safe Rate Score?+

The Safe Rate Score is a 0–100 composite index measuring a lender's performance across the 5 P's: Pricing, Pullthrough, Place, Product, and Promptness. Scores of 80 or above earn Champion status; scores of 60–79 earn Superstar status. Four of the P's are calculated from verified HMDA data and Promptness from real shopper quote requests — no lender can pay to improve their position.

How many mortgage lenders are active in Buffalo?+

Based on 2024 HMDA data, 63 lenders originated a combined 10,663 loans in Buffalo. Safe Rate's rankings evaluate all of them — not just a curated shortlist.

What does the rate spread tell me about a lender in Buffalo?+

Rate spread measures how much above the Average Prime Offer Rate (APOR) a lender charges. The median rate spread in Buffalo is 0.27%. Lenders in Safe Rate's top rankings consistently price below this median, meaning borrowers typically pay less interest over the life of their loan.

What is HMDA data and why does Safe Rate use it?+

HMDA (Home Mortgage Disclosure Act) is a federal law requiring every mortgage lender to disclose every loan application annually — including rates, amounts, approvals, and denials. Safe Rate uses HMDA because it is government-verified, covers all lenders equally, and cannot be gamed. It is the most objective foundation available for lender rankings.

Does Safe Rate accept payment from lenders to appear in rankings?+

No. Safe Rate rankings are strictly data-driven. No lender can pay to appear in or improve their position in Safe Rate's rankings. The only factor that determines a lender's rank is their verified HMDA performance data.

What is the difference between a bank, credit union, and independent mortgage company?+

Banks and credit unions offer mortgages alongside checking, savings, and other products. Independent Mortgage Companies (IMCs) focus exclusively on originating loans and often offer more product variety and speed. In Buffalo's rankings, all three institution types are evaluated on the same HMDA performance metrics.

How We Rank Lenders

Our rankings use an equal-weight average of scores across the 5 Ps: Pricing, Product, Pull-Through, Place, and Promptness. Promptness measures how quickly a lender answers real shopper quote requests; a lender with none measured yet is counted at an estimate.

Our Point System (Max 50 Points)

10/ 50 pts
Pricing
How competitively a lender prices vs. the market benchmark (20%).
10/ 50 pts
Product
Performance on your specific loan type (20%).
10/ 50 pts
Pull Through
How reliably a lender closes the loans it starts (20%).
10/ 50 pts
Place
Depth of a lender's expertise in your local market (20%).
10/ 50 pts
Promptness
How quickly a lender answers real quote requests — blended in once they respond (20%).

Data Integrity & Updates

Data is updated quarterly based on the latest HMDA filings and proprietary Safe Rate analysis. All metrics are calculated using standardized methodologies to ensure fair comparison across lenders.

Licensing & Disclosures

Lender rankings and market statistics are created by Dylan Hall, licensed mortgage loan officer (NMLS #1658740). Safe Rate is a mortgage technology platform; mortgage lending services are provided by PartnerOwn LLC dba Safe Rate Mortgage, a licensed mortgage broker and lender (NMLS #1590949). Safe Rate Mortgage is a lending partner of some of the lenders ranked on this page, and Safe Rate Inc. has software or service customers on this list; however, all rankings are calculated using objective, public Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) datasets, completely independent of any corporate partnerships, client relationships, or compensation.